Looks the same on day one: what is under your bathroom tiles in Canberra

If you are a Canberra homeowner comparing two bathroom quotes, here is the part neither photo shows: the five layers under the tiles, and which ones decide whether the floor cracks.

Written by Oleg Cha, owner of Apex Bathrooms ACT, renovating Canberra bathrooms since 2008. Updated

Tiled floor laid across a room, Canberra home

Two bathrooms, same day one

Picture two bathrooms on handover day. Same tiles, same vanity, same shower screen, same grout lines. You could swap the photos and nobody would notice. One of them will look like that for twenty years. The other will have a cracked tile by the second winter, a hollow sound under the shower by the third, and a grey line in the grout that comes back however often it is cleaned.

I have pulled out a lot of the second kind. We have renovated more than 800 bathrooms since 2008, and plenty of those jobs started with a bathroom that was only a few years old. The part that failed is never the part the owner chose. It is a layer under the tiles that they never saw and were never told about.

So this is the guide to those layers. There are five. I have put them in the order they go down.

Movement joint Tile Adhesive Waterproofing Single sheet Floor
Day one. All five layers, each one whole, and room to move where the floor meets the wall.
Crack Tile Adhesive Waterproofing Floor
Winter three. The same tile, with the layers under it thinned or missing: no sheet, thin waterproofing, adhesive in dabs and no room to move. The tile cracks.

Layer 1: the floor itself

Everything starts with what the house gives you. Most bathrooms here sit on a concrete slab, and a slab is a good start: it does not move much, and if it is sound, it is a floor you can tile.

Some homes have a timber floor instead, and that changes the job. A timber floor is a set of pieces that sit against each other and move a little every day: with the weather, with the house, with someone walking across it. Tile does not move. Put a thing that does not move on top of a thing that does, and the tile loses. That is the whole story of a cracked bathroom floor in one sentence, and it is the reason the next layer exists.

If a quote for a timber-floored bathroom does not say what the tiles are going onto, that is the first question to ask.

Layer 2: the sheet over timber

This is the one I talk about more than any other, because it is the cheapest layer to skip and the dearest to put back.

The shortcut is to tile straight onto the timber floor. The quote comes in lower because a step is missing. The tiles look perfect on day one. Then the timber does what timber does, the tiles follow it, and they crack. The owner pays a tiler to swap the broken ones, and the new ones crack too, because the floor underneath has not changed.

What I do instead is lay a single sheet across the whole floor so that it cannot move, and tile onto that. It adds to the price. The alternative, once the floor has failed, is demolition, the sheet, and tiling the bathroom again, which costs over $10,000. I set out that example in the cost guide, and it is the reason I tell every owner with a timber floor about the sheet before any work starts. I recommend it. The choice is yours.

Layer 3: the waterproofing

The membrane is the layer people have heard of, and still the one most often done badly, because it is invisible a week after it goes on.

It goes on in coats, each one cured before the next. In a Canberra winter that cure takes longer, and a schedule that has demolition, waterproofing and tiling all done in one week has no room in it for the cure. The junctions where the floor meets the wall get a bond breaker first, so the membrane can stretch where the building moves instead of tearing. The shower walls get the membrane to at least 1,800 mm. Then a licensed waterproofer inspects it and issues the compliance certificate, and nobody tiles until that certificate exists.

Every one of those steps can be skipped without anyone noticing on handover day. My waterproofing and ventilation guide goes through how each one fails, and what the certificate is worth when you sell the house. For this guide the point is simpler: the membrane is a layer, it sits under the tiles, and if it was rushed, the first sign is a wet patch on the other side of the wall two winters from now.

Layer 4: room to move

A tiled floor expands and contracts with the temperature, and this is a place with frosty mornings, hot dry afternoons and a big swing between the two. A floor laid tight to every wall, with no allowance for that, has nowhere to go. So it pushes against itself, and something gives: a tile lifts, a grout line crumbles, a crack runs across three tiles in a straight line.

The fix is movement joints: at the edges of the room and, in a bigger floor, at intervals across it. Where they go depends on the room, the floor under it and the tile, so I specify them for the job rather than take them off a rule of thumb. They are not expensive. They are just easy to leave out when nobody will see them, and in the floor tiling guide they are the first mistake on my list.

Layer 5: the adhesive and the level

The last layer before the tile is the bed it sits on. Two things go wrong here.

The first is a floor that was never made level before tiling started. A tile laid over a bump sits on the bump, with air under its corners. Step on it enough times and it rocks, then the grout cracks, then it sounds hollow, then it breaks. Levelling the floor first is dull work and nobody photographs it. It is also the reason a floor stays flat.

The second is the adhesive. Each tile needs a full, even bed of it, matched to the tile and to what it is going onto. Too little adhesive, or adhesive spread in dabs to save time, leaves hollows. Those are the tiles that sound empty when you tap them, and they are the ones that let go first when water gets in. The adhesive and the grout are both chosen for the tile, and my tiles and materials guide sets out how.

How to tell which bathroom you have

You do not need to lift a tile. Tap a few with a coin, in the shower and by the door. A tile that is sitting on a full bed sounds solid. A tile over a hollow rings. One hollow tile is a patch; a row of them is a bed that was never full. Then look at the cracks, if there are any. A crack across one tile is probably a dropped bottle. A crack that runs in a straight line through several tiles, or follows the join under the floor, is the layer underneath moving. The floor tiling guide has the full list of signs a floor is past repair, and when to patch and when to stop patching.

What this means for your quote

The five layers are the reason two quotes for the same bathroom can be thousands of dollars apart and still describe the same tiles. The cheaper one is often cheaper because a layer is thinner or missing. On day one you cannot tell. By the third winter you can.

So before I give you a final price, I look at the floor. The substrate is inspected before the quote is finalised, not after demolition when there is nothing to be done about it. If it is timber, you hear about the sheet. If the old membrane is missing or failed, which is common in the 1960s to 1980s brick houses across Belconnen, Woden and Tuggeranong, you hear about that too. Then you decide with the full picture, and the bathroom you pay for once is the one that lasts.

That is also why we back our bathrooms with a 10-year warranty. We go through what it covers when we quote your job.

Get your floor looked at

Build your bathroom in 3D in the instant quote designer and send it to us, then we come out, check the floor and quote it in writing. If you are worried about a floor you already have, send a photo and we will tell you honestly whether it is a repair or a rebuild. Ask for a fast free quote, see our bathroom renovations in Canberra, or look at recent work.

Design your bathroom in 3D

Build the room from our catalogue, send it to us, and we come back with a written, itemised quote after we have seen the space in Canberra.